Sunday, January 26, 2025

The Beak of the Starling

2024 started with a bang! On January 2, 2024 we published the results from our study on starlings in Scientific Reports. We used museum specimens and birds from the USDA to compare their morphology across the United States (through time and across the country) with those from the native range (U.K., parts of Eurasia). 

Here it is: Recent beak evolution in North American starlings after invasion

In 2024, I also finished a good portion of writing my book for Columbia University Press on starling science. It will likely be published by 2026. 

But starlings still continue to amaze me, in doing research for my book I learned that starlings are open-ended song learners which means they learn, add, and remix new songs throughout their whole life (unlike other birds which are closed-ended learners and learn their song at a critical period early in life and then sing the same song their whole life). And although starling males sing more elaborate songs and for longer durations than females, the females also sing and continue to learn...





Wednesday, May 31, 2023

Starling Updates in 2023

 Some exciting starling research updates for 2023!

1) Together with starling collaborators near and far, we published a Review Article in Biological Invasions, Global invasion history and native decline of the common starling: insights through genetics. 

2) I am thrilled to announce that I am writing a non-fiction, natural history book about Starlings - to be published by Columbia University Press! 

3) Our starling morphology manuscript, where we report rapid phenotypic change in North American starlings, is currently in review...

To be continued...

Sunday, December 18, 2022

The fault lies not in our starlings...

some starling updates (2022): 

1) I published a (fun) piece about starlings walking on the Upper West Side streets, here. 

2) I published a (more serious) article in the Connecticut Audubon State of Birds Report for 2022, which discusses recent research which shows that, contrary to popular belief, there is little evidence that starlings outcompete native birds in the US. 

3) The starling morphological evolution project is still underway, and we are excited to have new data coming in from birds in Wales, UK. Stay tuned for more on that in 2023...

4) With collaborators in Australia, we have a starling review paper coming out in Biological Invasions in 2023!

5) There is more that I hope to be able to share in a few months...

Monday, April 11, 2022

Scientific American Article

I published an opinion piece in Scientific American (May 3, 2021) about European starlings where I touch on topics such as: the lack of evidence for the Shakespeare connection, damage to farms, disease spread, the privilege of park going, and the health benefits of spending time in nature (with birds):

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-delight-of-watching-birds-on-the-streets-of-new-york/

Thursday, January 7, 2021

Starling updates

What a weird year it was, but things were pretty busy on the starling front and I wanted to share a few updates:

1) We published our Starling Mitochondrial DNA paper in Ecology & Evolution:  

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ece3.6679

2) The journal kindly asked us to write a blog about our paper! 

https://ecologyandevolution.blog/2020/08/28/mitochondrial-diversity-offers-insight-on-invasive-european-starling-populations-worldwide/

3) Our work was featured in Forbes! 

https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2020/09/16/does-genetic-diversity-aid-starling-invasions-around-the-world/?sh=148189127563

4) We spoke about our research at the American Museum of Natural History’s online SciCafe (video recording available upon request): 

https://www.amnh.org/learn-teach/adults/scicafe/starlings-invasion#:~:text=SciCafe%3A%20Shakespearean%20Bird%20Invasion,-Part%20of%20SciCafe&text=In%201890%2C%20approximately%20100%20birds,starlings%20in%20the%20US%20today.

5) I was featured on the College of Mount Saint Vincent website: 

https://mountsaintvincent.edu/the-engine-of-evolution/


And because we have no shortage of birds, or ideas, stay tuned for more to come...


Sunday, April 19, 2020

Mozart's Starling

I am finally getting around to reading the book Mozart’s Starling by Lyanda Lynn Haupt.

It is a well-researched, deftly written account of starlings, and focuses on two individual birds in particular. One, a pet starling kept by Mozart himself. The other, the author’s own pet starling that she raised from a chick. I cannot deny that her lovingly detailed account is making me want a pet starling more than anything. Because then, I could be learning from them all the time.

One excerpt from the book really struck me. It perfectly sums up the complexity of the relationship with these birds:

“Starlings are shimmering, plain, despised, charming, collectively devastating, individually fascinating. We have the capacity to realize that while a species may be ecologically undesirable, the individuals of the species are just birds. Beautiful, conscious, intelligent in their own right. Innocent. Do I want starlings gone? Erased from the face of North America? Yes, unequivocally. Do I resent them as aggressive invaders? Of course. And do I love them? Their bright minds, their sparkling beauty, their unique consciousness, their wild starling voices? Their feathers, brown from one angle, shining from another? Yes, yes, I do. ”





Thursday, May 9, 2019

European Starlings: Jerks, Bad Asses and New Yorkers

A short radio piece where I refer to European starlings as “bad asses”, for their adaptive flexibility, dispersal and expansion, and all-around industriousness. Not to diminish the seriousness of the threats they pose to native species, crops, livestock and airplanes - but just to say, they are biologically amazing, and don’t seem to care that they aren’t loved.

https://www.wshu.org/post/shakespeares-starlings#stream/0



Monday, June 12, 2017

learning to be a starling

It’s that time of year. The early summer, filled with wholesome expectations and tinted with the soft pain of change. The young starlings are out of their nests and on the city sidewalks. I saw one tweeting madly this morning, alone on a black metal fence. They are a modest deep grey now, unlike their more colorful, ostentatious parents. They look surprisingly large-bodied and grown up, especially for only 25 days old or so.

This year, for the starling project, the students created some truly beautiful bird skins. By that I mean they gutted the birds, turned the skin inside out, removed remaining bits of flesh, filled their body cavity with cotton, sewed them back together, and rearranged the plumage until they were returned to a bird-like body form again. This procedure is done to preserve the bird skin for future research purposes. Ornithologists who know how to do this, really know how to do it, but most people in the world, don’t. The process resembles cooking boldly and then carefully (but not eating), mending a ballet slipper, and petting a flower without losing petals. It requires a toughness, but also an extreme gentleness.

We could not have anticipated how much our students would excel at this new, sometimes disgust-inducing, precarious art. But they did.

The birds for our project are culled from airports, so they don’t fly into aircraft. Approximately 2 million starlings are killed this way every year (though this hardly puts a dent in the population of ~200 million in North America). Depredation methods range from trapping, cervical dislocation, and sometimes gunshot. Our birds this year had tiny holes in their skins from the latter. The students ever-so-gently mended the micro-tears in the skins. It would have been easy to: 1) give up. 2) make the mistake of creating a larger hole by tugging the delicate skin. But they didn’t.





The juvenile birds in particular, have slightly thinner skins than the adults (see image above, and the bird all the way to the right in the bottom picture). I love the idea of the students mending the young birds, and learning to be scientists. And I love to see the juvenile starlings, out of the nests now, learning to be starlings. 

Wednesday, December 28, 2016

Go Forth

The range of European starlings in North America extends northward to Alaska. We think this range is the result of the 1890 introduction (i.e. invasion) of these birds. The native range of European starlings spreads across Europe and Asia, stretching as far East as Mongolia. Soon we will receive modern birds from Alaska, which made me remember a good question from a student a few years ago. Did starlings arrive in Alaska from their southern invasive range, or from their native range to the west? European starlings are not traditionally regarded as migratory birds. That means they do not fly over long distances seasonally to breed, though some starling populations are exceptions to this. But European starlings have been experts in rapidly and permanently expanding their range. So, some starlings go back and forth, and some just go forth.

The movement of starlings across the Alaskan landscape reminds me of a recent study about early human migrations. Though by feet not flight, humans may (or may not) have traversed a similar path, and with similar rip-roaring gusto. The traditional story is that the first humans arrived in North America across the Bering Straight from Siberia via a now long-gone land bridge. Some scientists have recently suggested that although the land bridge was present 13,000 years ago, the conditions in the region would not have allowed humans to survive (Pederson et. al, 2016). The landscape was barren with no exploitable resources for food or shelter. It was the Ice Age after all, not exactly a time of warmth and abundance. The authors go on to say that perhaps humans arrived via a different, unknown seafaring route. No matter which route they arrived, I always think of those first migrants. Human migrations did not complete themselves within the lifetime of one individual. But that does not mean that brave explorer types did not exist thousands of years ago in the human population. Undoubtedly, these individuals would make Columbus and Darwin look like wimps. The world was wilder then. Imagine going out in the morning and not knowing if continuous land lay ahead? or if you would find familiar food? And you would be a prisoner of the daily cycles of light or dark, and of the unusually long days, or continuous Alaskan nights. It makes my risk-averse body shiver.

A unique quality that humans have, that separates us from other species like birds, is that one individual can have an impact for years to come via the cultural transmission of information for generations. We have key people throughout history who, for better or worse, leave a mark on the population. Then, generations later we remember that person. But was their a starling Elvis Presley, or an Abraham Lincoln starling? The answer is no, but also kind of yes. We do see a few individuals that lead what we call the expanding front of birds. These are the birds on the edge of the group that led the species further into new localities. What was it about those individuals that made them fly farther in a new direction than any starling had before? And maybe the movement wasn’t very far, just a few new miles within their lifetime. They also didn’t know they were explorers. They weren’t leaving a flag in the ground or posing for grainy photographs, they were just eating different caterpillars and living in a new old tree. We can measure their wings, legs, bodies, and learn something about the geographic distribution of genetic diversity to understand more. The answer for why they moved is probably food or safety. This is likely the same reason early humans moved too. No one was running from war or towards religious freedom. Yet. But the new question is how did they adapt to new environments so well? Among hominins, we credit Homo sapiens with the astonishing capability to adapt to new highly varied environments. But the story of European starlings in North America is also one of amazing adaptive flexibility.

In humans, a specific genetic variant of a dopamine receptor gene called DRD4 has been linked to “novelty seeking behavior”. People with the shorter version of this gene are less likely to explore, and those with longer versions are more likely to explore. Some authors have suggested this allele played a role in the behavior of the original human explorers (Matthews and Butler, 2011). In birds, a specific genetic variant of the ADCYAP1 gene has been implicated in seasonal migratory behavior (Mueller et. al., 2011). But we know birds, just like humans, expanded their ranges too. Who were those first starlings that went forth into Alaska and didn’t go back? Why did they go? How did they adapt? They were not what we should call brave, but they were almost certainly, different.






Monday, February 8, 2016

The Nature of Colonialism



When I was reading the chapter on European starlings in Tinkering With Eden: A Natural History of Exotics in America by Kim Todd, there was one thing that kept flashing in my head: colonialism.

Read this section from Todd’s novel:
“If starlings have a noteworthy genetically programmed personality characteristic, it is aggression. They wait until other birds have created cavities for nests, then harass the architects until they abandon their site. Sometimes a starling enters a hole while the owner is gone. When the bird returns, the starling leaps onto its back, clinging and pecking it all the way to the ground. Even when it has claimed a nesting cavity, a starling may continue to abuse other birds breeding nearby, plucking their eggs out of the nest and dropping them in the dirt. One ornithologist watched a starling dangle a piece of food in front of the nesting cavity of a downy woodpecker. When the young woodpecker reached out of the hole for the bait, the starling dispatched it with a quick jab of the beak…Two cottonwoods on land hosted fourteen pairs of breeding native birds in 1978, but in early 1979 a starling couple moved in. Then a dozen more joined them…the starlings scared off American kestrels, northern flickers, olive sided flyercatchers, and house wrens in March. In April and May morning doves, tree swallows, and house finches approached the cottonwoods, only to be rebuffed. By June the trees were only offering refuge to nothing but starlings.”

The section reminded me of Edmund Morgan’s recall of history in Early Virginia, American Slavery, and American Freedom: “Since the Indians were better woodsmen than the English and virtually impossible to track down, the method was to feign peaceful intentions, let them settle down and plant their corn wherever they chose, and then, just before harvest, fall upon them, killing as many as possible and burning the corn…”

Humans often pride ourselves with not being animalistic, not acting savagely. However, these British colonists acted in ways that can only be comparable to animalistic ritual behavior. British colonialism is a harsher, crueler, and comparable personification to the spread and destruction caused by European starlings.

The patterns of behavior are so similar that the same language can be used to describe the actions of both the violence caused by European starlings and colonists. For example:

If the British colonists had a noteworthy genetically programmed personality characteristic, it is aggression. They waited until the indigenous communities settled down and planted their corn, then harassed the architects by setting the land on fire and raiding the homes of the indigenous communities until they abandoned their site...Two pieces of land hosted fourteen indigenous families in a tribe in 1808, but in 1809 an American couple moved in. Then a dozen more families joined them…the Americans scared off  the indigenous communities by harassing and pushing them off the land. By June the land only offered refuge to nothing but American colonists.

When the history and behavior of European starlings are studied it is strikingly analogous to the histories and behaviors of European colonists. When looking at the places European starlings have invaded: Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Falkland Islands, Mexico, Peru, New Zealand, United States, North America, New Zealand, and South Africa—the countries all have one thing in common: they all have been colonized by Europe. Thus, there is a causation relationship between colonialism by European colonists and European starlings; without the colonialism that occurred, starlings would not have been able to be introduced to the lands they now conquer and terrorize.

When we talk about invasive species, we use the same kind of language when we are describing European colonialism. However, our perceptions of the two things are different: we easily perceive invasive species as detrimental, harmful, and something to be prevented at all costs. This is different from our perceptions of colonialism, which were sometimes seen as benevolent and inevitable. Research institutions and scientists work to secure resources to preserve endangered animals and species—the same resources and energy were not used to ensure the prosperity of indigenous communities throughout history. 

Guest Blogger: J. Raihan

map color key: 
light yellow=Introduced European starling summer breeding range
light green=Introduced European starling resident range
dark yellow=Native European starling summer breeding range 
dark green=Native European starling resident range
dark blue=Native European starling winter range

Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Sculptures and Superorganisms

The word murmuration typically refers to a soft, indistinct sound, but in the more rare sense of the word, it refers to a flock of starlings. The first and only time I ever witnessed a starling murmuration was through a laptop screen – yet I was spellbound. The amoeba-like conglomeration of birds seemed to float through space, both fluid and structured at the same time. The dying hues of the setting sun illuminated the gaps between each bird like light through a mesh screen. When I saw this phenomenon, the first thing that came to mind was a term I’d heard about recently: superorganism.
A biologist coined that word for our great African ant colonies, claiming that consciousness and intelligence resided not in the individual ant but in the collective ant mind. Essentially, the superorganism is an organism consisting of many organisms. But I don’t think the concept is reserved solely for animals – I see it in the cars humming by on the highway and the people bustling in the Times Square subway station.

Another biologist – Ian Couzin – has been doing similar work at Princeton University and has found, through computer simulations and mathematical algorithms, that there are indeed many similarities between different levels of organization in nature. It is essentially a biological criticality: when a neighbor moves, so do you. It’s a system that is poised to tip, to be almost instantly and completely transformed.

Something else that surfaced in my mind while watching the murmurations was the work of an artist named Ruth Asawa, whose work I’d recently seen at the Whitney Museum of American Art. Asawa is an artist who learned to draw in an internment camp for Japanese-Americans during World War II and later earned renown weaving wire into intricate, flowing, fanciful abstract sculptures. She started using wire after a trip to Mexico in 1947, and used the craftsmanship she had learned from Mexican basket makers as well as her ambition to extend line drawings into a third dimension. In 1958, The New York Times wrote of her sculptures’ “gossamer lightness” and the way “the circular and oval shapes seem like magic lanterns, one within the other.” In a way, I think these adjectives perfectly describe the starling murmurations as well.

Thus whether we are looking at birds or humans, sculptures or superorganisms, there are some elements which remain undeniably the same – organization, fluctuation, and variability, to name a few. And by viewing Asawa’s hanging mobiles and the starling murmurations side by side, I think it becomes clear that the dichotomy between art and science may not be as rigid as it seems.

Guest blogger: K.S. Mediratta 

Sunday, December 27, 2015

big data, big ideas and a big gorilla

Not a raindrop, or a mushroom, or a dark-eyed junco, just a “ >” and a “#” and a “/”. 

I have been thinking a lot about the paradigm shift in biology towards the computational analysis of big datasets. The most important skill-set for modern biologists is no longer getting crazy dirty, sweaty and blissed-out studying wild populations in the field -- but understanding how to analyze big datasets, at your computer, sitting on your butt, in your half-office. 


Now, you can be a biologist and study gigabytes of information about the natural world (DNA sequences, gene expression data, geographic distributions etc.) without ever being close to a bit of anything natural. Or you can be a biologist who studies the natural world, but does not really know the modern methods of study, just browsing the forest with a keen eye, an old-fashioned big idea (and a little secret). Are either of these biologists compromised, or can they both add valuable knowledge to our understanding of the world? Who wins: the indoorsy computer nerd, or the wild energetic explorer? Blessed are the unicorns who are both, but let’s imagine one isn’t. 


These seemingly disparate activities are unified by thoughtfully designed research questions, and the traits of curiosity, critical thinking and grit. Wake up again and walk into the cool morning forest to find species x, even though you would rather rest more in your crappy tent. Wake up again and work on the script that won’t work, even though you would rather rest more on your pillow-top mattress. Nothing is working, so think of a new approach. Didn’t get the grant you applied for? rewrite and resubmit. Paper got rejected? resubmit to another journal. Whatever it is, forest or FASTA, poison or polytomy, keep going, keep looking and keep thinking critically and creatively. 


So, what can we teach students who are interested in natural history and genetics
 that now need to know Python and R? Do we start by teaching the mechanics of Python, and save the actual pythons for later? And what if you like catching snakes, but you aren’t good at, or drawn to, coding? Is there a place for you as a biologist in this new computational jungle? 

E.O. Wilson said that you don’t have to be great at math to be a biologist, some people freaked out about this. But what he said echoes into the practice of bioinformatics too. Can you be a computer dud, but still do science today? And will this new computational paradigm favor computer wizards who may not know, or care, about complex biological processes like species formation or migrations? And how do you learn to care about these abstract processes if not by seeing and knowing the breathtaking bird, or the scales of the snake, or the big gorilla itself? 

Sunday, August 16, 2015

Darkness at the edge of wonder

The starling’s beaks are darkening into a marbleized browny black for late summer. They are no longer the cheery yellow of the breeding season.

As an educator working with high school students in an informal scientific learning environment, our great goal is to inspire students about the wonders of the natural world. We regale them with tales of discovery, dazzle them with biodiversity, and let them experience the highs of self-directed inquiry. This requires an enthusiastic, optimistic, and sometimes histrionic teaching approach.

But, the reality of doing science is not all awe-inspiring. Most times it is the opposite. Most times it is a thankless slog, indistinguishable at the daily level from other detail-oriented, challenging jobs. Most times things don’t work as planned, and there is no discovery, just confusion followed by more confusion, stress, and then disappointment.


It is a life of the lab, of the accidentally dropped 96 samples; a life of the forest, drenched in sweat and not having seen a single species-you-came-for all day. It is a life of the desert, hunched over hunting for fossils and finding nothing. It is a life of awkwardness, bad advice, insecurity, and mountains of other people’s arrogance. It is a life of having to prove yourself, right after having just proved yourself. But it is also, a life of the mind, which is the big yellow hope that guides us through the darkness. Asking a question with an answer that is millions of years old, making a new connection, illuminating a pattern, or uncovering unknown diversity. It is all gloriously bigger than us. And no wasted day in the lab or the field can take away the intellectual euphoria that accompanies this imperfect journey. 


But what can we tell our students, that will speak to the darkness, but not turn them away? And maybe some of them should be turned away. It is not for everyone. It is not for most people. It makes no sense, and yet perfect sense. 


Most times you find nothing, but keep looking darlings. Their beaks will be yellow again in spring.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

I saw your heart

Last week we prepared starling specimens as if they were bound for a research collection. We skinned them, gutted them, stuffed them, and sewed them back together again into a once-and-beautiful-bird. We sat in almost-silence learning how all the pieces fit together, by slowly ripping them apart. 

I once posed a question on my blog asking biologists to tell me why they work with the species—or group of species—that they do. Is it because they are a model for understanding humans? or because of their interesting behavior, morphology, or adaptations? or maybe, you are just flat-out inexplicably drawn to them? Unscientifically adoring of your fascinating and sweet species. You watch them move in the wild, you know their tendencies, and how to tell individuals of the same species apart. You get a rush when you see something rare. You think about them all the time. We cannot deny that we are moved by the animal kingdom, yet I have been told in so many ways that it’s not typical or acceptable to bring these feelings to scientific inquiry. But I truly think it is artificial to pretend otherwise. Give me a break. I know what science is, and what it isn’t. I trust my measurements are not inaccurate because my eyes are blurry with tears. I can quantify something cute. And isn't knowing about something, wholly and deeply, the most comprehensive kind of love? 

First, we blew gently on the ventral side of the tiny body so the feathers naturally parted. We slowly sliced into the starling flesh. We started in the middle of the chest. And worked our way towards the head. We stripped the flesh away from the skin on the inside of the breast and then wings and legs. We removed the guts. Then, we did something unthinkably weird. We inverted the head so that the skull was inside the body cavity, and the skin that was previously over the head was a headless floppy feathery costume. We cut the back of the skull open, and removed the brain tissue. We popped each eye out. Then, the brainless, eyeless, skull went back inside its original skin. We made small cotton stand-ins for where the eyes had been, and pushed them through the bloody neck back into the orbits. The wing bones were tied together on the inside of the skin. The leg bones were wrapped in cotton, which looked like some kind of last ditch effort at wound care of a badly bedraggled bird-thing. We stuffed the inside of the chest cavity with cotton, reestablishing the original plumpness of the living bird, and we sewed it up with a needle and thread. My colleague spent time lovingly straightening the feathers. We crossed the legs, and tied them together with a string, which felt like we were finally laying this little life to rest. 

Sentimentality has no place in science, so I will stop by saying thank you specimen #8, you helped me learn about bird anatomy, and how to prepare a study specimen, and through that process, I can say I saw your heart. 





















Wednesday, May 13, 2015

spring starlings

It was a long winter. All winters are long. Spring is undoubtedly here. First the white flowering pear trees, then daffodils, pink cherry blossoms, outdoor cafes and seasonal allergies. It’s all here. And —as always—it’s warm and hopeful and glorious.

We spent the fall and winter collecting genetic data from our modern (airport) specimens. Now we can spend time this spring watching the starlings behave. In early April, I started noticing more starlings on the museum lawn. Now, they are everywhere. Their beaks are yellow, their plumage is getting shinier, and they are pecking furiously at the grass. Grackles, pigeons, sparrows, and robins are out there too. But starlings are unmistakable, even from a distance, with their long legs and distinct gait. They look more comfortable walking on the ground than some other birds. They are at my bus stop in the morning, and again when I arrive at the museum. Sometimes they fly alongside the moving bus. They sport triangular wings while in flight and, needless to say, move much faster than the bus.

Their plumage changes with the seasons. It is not a color change though, it is a shedding of the little light colored bits on the ends of their winter feathers. Then, for the breeding season, they are ready to strut around in their more flashy iridescent feathers. Their beaks turn from brown in fall to yellow in spring. I always cherish the onset of spring, but it is my first year really noticing the starling’s seasonal transition, which —just like the warmth and the blossoms—is predictable and comforting and totally marvelous.

*I need a new starling picture for my blog header, send me your pics of spring starlings!*   




                                                                     image from animals.nationalgeographic.com

Sunday, April 12, 2015

Adventure is for the birds

Six o’clock was approaching in inconceivable leaps. You label the tubes, I’ll label the package. We send our DNA out for sequencing, which means we ship little tubes of clear liquid in an envelope to New Jersey. In a few days, we receive a computer file with strings of A’s, C’s, G’s and T’s that we carefully analyze for key differences. The last package pickup is at 6:00pm. We were running late.

I took the envelope and ran through the grand halls of my work place; past the 145 year old canoe, through the 1950’s forest, past protists and dodos and horeshoe crabs. It was a natural history themed This is your Life episode. I felt fleet-footed and brave.

This project is not a traditional adventure. No traveling to far off places to collect rare specimens, no field clothes, no tent sleeping. No plane ticket, no goodbyes. All the work occurs less than 2 miles from my apartment. Specimens are sent directly to me. Even my “time travel” to collect historical specimens involved going in some very nearby doors I had never entered. Maybe I am missing out, or maybe I am incredibly lucky.

Out of breath from my run, I reached the desk. “Did I miss package pickup?”, “No”. My mind sailed away to temporary confident places, I did it! imagine what other impossible things I am capable of? I think about these birds constantly. I regularly wonder what the complete data will show. I am dying to know. I am an over-thinker, but I am also an immovable beast, I don’t love going places like everyone around me seems to. I recently diagnosed myself as an indoor dreamer. But even though I haven’t crossed rapids, or hiked for hours, the intellectual journey is an adventure to me, one that I would gladly run through the halls to achieve.

After my focus returned, the man took my package and smiled, “the last pickup is 8:00pm”. Ashamed, exalted, I told him about my gloriously unnecessary run, and how great it felt. He told me to run back. So I did.

Thursday, March 12, 2015

Bird heaven

Thousands of specimens sit in silence, waiting for a scientific research question to give them life. Birds from different decades sit together in one drawer. Birds that lived thousands of miles apart might share a cabinet. It is a time capsule, and a pile of places — it is a collapsed little world.

I have been dreaming of this starling project for months. What motivates me is not their striking beauty, or their precious handwritten specimen tags, it is looking for patterns and tracing the biological legacy of their dramatic story. I sat at my desk and stared out the sliver of almost-window, I read, and researched, and emailed about it. But what I didn’t realize is that the historical specimens that would allow me to understand how the species changed through time were sitting —without much exaggeration—on the other side of my office wall. Behind my office wall there is a bathroom, and then not far beyond that, it is bird heaven.







Tuesday, January 27, 2015

old little toes

Are New Yorker starlings different than Californian? I would bet yes, but how so? some do yoga, others drink too much coffee and double park? Maybe. 

We are studying starling populations throughout North America to detect genetic and phenotypic differences across the country. But, aside from detecting geographic variation, we also want to chronicle how the species has changed over time. For this, we will look inside hidden museum collections. Museum research collections are important scientific repositories for data that are otherwise inaccessible to researchers. Some specimens may represent species, or populations, that are now rare or extinct. It is critically important for the advancement of science to maintain and make available the specimens within research collections. Thousands upon thousands of specimens of birds, mammals, reptiles and fish have been collected, prepared, stored, and made available for research purposes like this project. 


We will be soon receiving 33 samples of starlings from The Field Museum. We will not receive whole birds in a bag, or a box, as we have before. The samples will consist of small pieces of old little toe pads cut from bird specimens. Some from England, others from the East Coast of the US—all old, some over 100 years. From these pieces, we will extract ancient DNA. This will bring a new dimension to our starlings study. I am thrilled.


We can answer questions like: Have North American starlings lost genetic diversity over their 100 year time here? Have some genetic groups gone extinct? Do starlings in North America have less genetic variation than those in England from the time of their original arrival in 1890? 

And I keep thinking of the hilarious Big Lebowski toe storyline: I can get you a toe by 3 O'clock. 

Sunday, January 18, 2015

strange familiar birds

Their beaks are brown for winter, their plumage blurry with stars. They convene on the sidewalk for a brief bird-minute, and I stare at them as if I will be able to see urban evolution in action. I haven’t seen it yet, but I know that it is there; in their genes, in their bones, and in that walk - that rises and falls with a graceless bounding pride. What can we learn from these strange familiar birds?

The concept for this project grew out of a basic evolutionary question I had about how populations evolve. We know that a dramatic and prolonged decrease in population size results in lower genetic diversity, and stronger genetic drift 
for succeeding generations. But what happens to morphology under these conditions? I don’t think there is one answer for all taxa. Variation differs from species to species, and from trait to trait. Because of the stunning history of starlings in our country, I am deeply curious about the diversity of their skeletons, feathers and beaks. By bringing a cage full of lively birds from England to the US and releasing them in Central Park, an accidental evolutionary experiment began in the winter of 1890 - one that we are following up on today.

The data are coming in. Our sturnus vulgaris mitochondrial DNA sequences look clean and strong. One goal of our project is to better understand the genetic diversity of North American (NA) starlings, and compare that to other sturnus vulgaris populations around the globe. The expectation is that genetic diversity will be low in NA starlings because of the small size of their founding population (60 individuals in 1890), and their rapid expansion (to 200,000,000 in just 125 years). It is too early to tell how much, or how little variation, we have yet. I am highly hopeful that we will get solid results this year. We are lucky to have the great help of wildlife authorities throughout the country for suppling birds. And I am working together with two conscientious students who are doing careful lab work. We have started a database for recording information about each specimen. It is exciting to see it grow. Data accumulation is one of the great thrills of doing science, it’s work made visible.